dear citibank,

citi 3

(Warning: this post is somewhat of a rant. If you aren’t in the mood, turn away now.)

Prior to being a stepmom in Chester County, I spent years in the financial services industry including as a Compliance Officer. So I am very familiar with how banks and other institutions should send out customer correspondence.

This morning as I am editing some photos the doorbell rings.  A UPS man had dropped an envelope on the front porch. The envelope is from Citibank, N.A. I opened it not thinking initially it could be addressed to someone else.  We don’t have accounts with Citibank, so I did not know why they were contacting us.

Turns out the correspondence was for a woman who used to live in the house, but had been dead for close to three years.

I start reading this letter addressed to the “Estate of Mrs. X” . They (Citibank) open by extending condolences a few years too late. Then they state how they have closed the account referenced above (I whited out the number for this post, but they disclosed the entire account number of this credit card) and apologized for any inconvenience and if anyone in the house was using this card they can call 1-800-456-4277 to apply for their own card. Then they say if the records are incorrect and Mrs. X is still alive, accept their apologies and basically let them know to reactivate account.  They sign the letter Credit Management Department 1-866-775-0556.

As someone who used to work in the financial services industry I was appalled by the phraseology and the unabashed shill to try to get a dead woman’s relatives to sign up for a credit card. I was also profoundly disturbed that they sent a letter to an Estate where they did not even check to see if the address was legitimate still and disclosed not only the decedent’s name but her  ENTIRE account number. People, even dead people, have become victims of identity theft on far less information – the news has these horror stories far too often it seems. (My bank and credit card company which are different institutions do NOT disclose my entire account number on any statements and correspondence that gets mailed.)

So I call up Citibank to (a) tell them they are sending correspondence to my home to a woman who has been dead quite a while and to (b) to ask them to correct the address of record.

I get a “helpful” customer service representative who says they found out only recently this woman had died due to another account she had with Citibank.

O.K. too much information. I am not a relative or estate attorney or executor and if I was I should have to be able to give them proof of such standing before any conversation took place.

So I said to her I had not received other correspondence from Citibank so why would they send account information here when they had another address for whatever the other accounts were?

Very annoyed. I had some nerve asking a reasonable and logical question.

So I then told her how distasteful in general I found the letter along with foolhardy. Foolhardy as they disclosed to me a stranger an account number and did not verify a proper address for estate paperwork before sending anything out.  Distasteful because they are on one hand offering condolences but on the other hand pimping for new customers, but oh yeah if Mrs. X really isn’t dead let’s get her hooked up with more credit again.

Very annoyed again.

So here’s to you Citibank.  I don’t think I could ever open any account with you given this whole thing.  I want my financial institutions to safeguard all my information, and if I had any deceased relatives where I was executrix, I would want the same thing.

Financial institutions are sloppy.  They have rules and regulations they are supposed to follow with regard to client accounts, and once anything gets tagged “estate” they are supposed to be even more vigilant.

Aesop’s moral to this story is make sure accounts are CLOSED when you close them.

do banks actually offer good old fashioned customer service any longer?

PNC PNC Bank this post is for you.

I am super cranky this morning.  I have come to the realization that perhaps non-millionaire (i.e. average) customers are not valued by America’s banks after all, which makes you understand why some people keep their money in their proverbial mattresses.

hippiesSo over the Memorial Day Weekend I went out to Milkhouse Antiques, which just had a name change and ownership change to Antiques at Silver Bell Farms  (and yes that is confusing right now because there are TWO Facebook Pages – the former Milkhouse page and the newer Good Ol’ Days- Antiques at Silver Bell Farm).  Anyway, I purchased a couple of things for my garden including this crazy funny sign that says “Hippies Use Side Door” (and not to grouse, but I discovered I could have purchased online for significantly less but am happy I was able to patronize a local business).

When I went to check out and to pay for my items, inadvertently another item was added to my bill so they had to void my original sale and re-ring my items.  They gave me all the receipts and I did not think another thing about it.

Until yesterday.

Yesterday I went to check my bank account to discover that the correct charge and the erroneous charge were still on my account. I called up the store and the new owner was super nice to me but said my bank needed to remove the incorrect charge.

So this morning I checked my account again and it was still there so I decided to call up PNC Bank.  I spent a frustrating 30 minutes trying to navigate the new auto attendant before I could reach a LIVE customer service person.  When I did they were perfectly pleasant but told me basically I was S.O.L. until it magically falls off (which after in essence five business days it has not) and there was nothing that PNC could do for me.

Basically my only choice is to  have this small business write and fax a letter to PNC on their letterhead asking for charge to be released or removed.  Her justification was “they placed it there” , meaning the small business.

Yeah and nevermind the fact they control the account and I spent over two decades working in bank and brokerage and know that exceptions can be made and accounts adjusted on the end of the bank.

Yeah and nevermind they have no idea how this can disrupt the day of a small business which would then in turn make that business not value me as a customer.

So I have sent all of this along to the small business in the hopes that maybe their bank can talk to my bank.

What I want to know is what happened to customer service?  I know I am not a huge customer but I have been a long-term customer.

Sign me frustrated.

So what kind of customer service do you get at your bank?